Published 3/20/2012

Stabilizing a CNC Machining Process

Process stability problems often can be attributed to the appropriateness of workholding devices and cutting tools.

CNC Tech Talks

Mike Lynch

Founder and President, CNC Concepts Inc.

The stability of any process directly contributes to how easy it is for setup people and operators to complete production runs. Assuming these people know how to set up and operate machines, process-stability problems often can be attributed to the tooling.

For example, an adequate workholding device ensures that the workpiece doesn’t move or flex during machining operations. It can optimize cutting conditions and minimize cycle-completion time. However, if workholding is inadequate, machining workpieces to required specifications might not be possible.

The same is true for cutting tools. An assembled cutting tool must be rigid enough to optimize cutting conditions. Anything less causes inefficient machining operations. In the worst-case scenario, it is not possible to machine without chatter.

Use the following three steps to ensure CNC machining process stability:

1. Make good workpieces. Unfortunately, it can be difficult to tell if a given tooling problem is workholding or cutting tool related—or both. Inadequate workholding that causes the workpiece to flex has the same effect as a flexing cutting tool. Either case results in chatter or the inability to consistently machine surfaces within tolerance bands. On the other hand, a workholding device that grasps the workpiece too tightly can deform it. When released at the end of the cycle, it will spring back to its original shape, causing machined surfaces to move out of their tolerance bands.

2. Ensure that CNC operators can perform required tasks at the same rate as the machine. The operator must be able to keep up with the machine for the process to be stable. For example, operators must be able to quickly and easily replace and secure workpieces. They should also be able to perform any tasks related to workpiece cleaning and deburring, measurement, and sizing adjustments during the CNC cycle.

3. Ensure that an acceptable period of unattended operation can be achieved. By unattended operation, I’m not necessarily talking about eliminating all human responsibilities. While there are situations that require long periods of completely unattended operation, most CNC processes require operator involvement at least once per cycle to load and unload workpieces.

Instead, I’m talking about being able to machine at an acceptable level without too much operator involvement. The single, largest problem in this regard is selecting optimum cutting conditions for reasonable cutting tool life. Admittedly, this is rather subjective. A common mistake is to select overly aggressive cutting conditions to machine workpieces faster. This often causes cutting tools to wear more quickly than they should as well as excessive tool maintenance.

Production-run volumes dictate what to do in this regard. With small lots, all cutting tools likely will last the entire production run without dulling. No compromise in cutting conditions may be necessary unless the same cutting tools are used from job to job. In this case, compromises can minimize excessive operator intervention. As lot sizes grow, it becomes more likely that tool maintenance will be required during the production run.

If the machine must be down during tool maintenance, it is important to find a good compromise between cutting conditions and tool life, especially for long production runs. However, some tool-life management systems enable tool maintenance to be completed while the machine is in production. This is accomplished by using multiple, identical cutting tools and ensuring that operators can remove and replace dull tools while the machine is in cycle. With this kind of system, compromising cutting conditions is not as important because tool maintenance is done during production.

One last point that I’ll make about tooling-related process stabilization has to do with engineering involvement. In many companies I visit, CNC setup people and operators are left completely on their own to get jobs up and running and keep them that way. While they get the job done, they might be using questionable methods to do so.

The compromises setup people and operators make between cutting conditions and tool maintenance tend to err on the side of making tools last as long as possible. With more appropriate cutting conditions, workpieces can be made more efficiently, without excessive tool maintenance. As another example, operators often change/index all cutting components (inserts) at the beginning of every shift. This wastes time and tooling. Unless engineering/management get involved, these wasteful methods will go unnoticed.

Related Content

Basics 27 Nov 2024

How to Determine the Currently Active Work Offset Number

Determining the currently active work offset number is practical when the program zero point is changing between workpieces in a production run.

Machining Centers 16 Aug 2024

4 Commonly Misapplied CNC Features

Misapplication of these important CNC features will result in wasted time, wasted or duplicated effort and/or wasted material.

CNC Tech Talks 21 Oct 2024

2 Secondary Coordinate Systems You Should Know

Coordinate systems tell a CNC machine where to position the cutting tool during the program’s execution for any purpose that requires the cutting tool to move.

CNC Tech Talks 30 Aug 2023

Troubleshooting Differences in Programming Methods, Machine Usage

Regardless of the level of consistency among machines owned by your company, you probably have experienced consistency-related issues. Here are some tips to help solve them.

Cutting Tools

A New Frontier in Surface Finish Control

What if your machine tool could measure surface roughness as it cuts? This article explores how in-process metrology is advancing from concept to reality, enabling real-time feedback, immediate detection of anomalies and new levels of control over surface quality. Discover the technologies making this possible.

How I Made It

How I Made It: Dennis Rymanowski

Dennis Rymanowski has worked at NSH USA for 60 years, with his passion for manufacturing living alongside his passion for his family’s polka band.

Stabilizing a CNC Machining Process